All seven restaurants that earned the rare three-star rating last year were awarded the same rating this year.
There was, however, one shakeup at the top. Experimental tasting table atera, which opened in Tribeca in March, earned two stars, putting it in the company of Marea and Momofuku Ko.
Business Insider's Henry Blodget was lucky enough to nab an early seat at atera, which is owned by Jodi Richard, wife of Business Insider co-founder (and founder of DoubleClick, Gilt Grouple, and 10gen, among others) Dwight Merriman.
Take a look at his meal, which included "moss" and "rocks," and which he calls one of the best dining experiences of his life.
Atera is on Worth Street, in Manhattan, a few blocks from the Brooklyn Bridge. It only seats about 20 people.
The seating is built around the kitchen, so you watch everything the chefs and waiters do. Part of what they do is explain what you're about to eat, which is extremely helpful.
Atera's owner Jodi Richard and GM Eamon Rockey found Atera's chef, Matthew Lightner, in Portland, Oregon, after flying all around the country eating people's food. Matt had been named one of the best new chefs in America in 2010. Some of the conservative folks in Portland, however, were apparently a bit freaked out by his food.
Some Portland folks were freaked out because Lightner makes what is described as "modern" food. The food is influenced by at least two recent culinary trends: "Foraging," which involves the use of strange, wild ingredients, and "molecular gastronomy," which applies scientific engineering to food. Lightner grows all his own herbs hydroponically, in a basement room at Atera. Here's a fresh batch in the "test kitchen."
Upstairs, in the dining room, one of the walls is made of plants. It smells nice--like an herb garden. By the way, when Jodi Richard was buying the hydroponic equipment to grow the herbs, the hydroponics dealer was convinced she was building an industrial-scale pot farm. "Cash only," they said.
Before the first course, though, Atera's sommelier popped over. His name is Alex LaPratt. He was recently named one of the best sommeliers in the country. In 97 days, he's going to take a test to become a "master" sommelier. There are only about 200 of them in the world.
Alex brought us a bottle of Riesling. For several reasons, I don't normally drink. Last night, I decided to drink. Then "snacks" started to arrive. Like granola dipped in a sesame sauce and frozen.
The food isn't the only stuff at Atera that is home made. All the plates and bowls are, too. And the boxes. And the table. And the light fixtures. And the lights.
The second group of snacks featured "fois gras peanuts," a chip of some sort, and pickled quail eggs. As we ate all these things, I began to consider the possibility that my contribution to Dwight and Jodi's local startup might not end up being as "minor" as I had expected.
"Atera," by the way, does not mean "of the earth," as I had surmised. It's a Basque word. It means "go out." Snack number three last night was razor clams served on stone.
By 930pm, we were done with the snacks. We were also done with the Riesling. So Alex had popped over with a bottle of Montrachet. And dinner started to arrive. Starting with yogurt, nuts, freeze-dried fruit, and a beet. This was not the last beet we would see.
Diver scallops, sliced, layered between citrus slices and "gin botanicals." Atera's chefs, by the way, don't just throw this stuff together. They assemble it. With tweezers.
And then a mystery course that we were asked to eat first and then guess what we were eating. My philistine guess, which I was too embarrassed to share, was "some kind of fish." I was kind of in the ballpark, at least with one of the ingredients. It was "squid flake" served with bacon fat and squid broth.
Between every course, by the way, the waiters swapped out our utensils, arriving with new ones in a box like this. If you're going to eat squid flake, there's no sense in diluting it with fluke after-taste.
It was while eating the squab, I think, which came with pear skins (those curly things) that I concluded that my contribution to Dwight and Jodi's little local startup was not going to be minor at all, especially considering the Montrachet and Riesling.
It is hard to even begin to convey how fan-fracking-tastically cool "rock" was, especially after a bottle of Riesling and Montrachet. "Rock," it turned out was bergamot sorbet in some sort of candy shell on a bed of "wheatberry gravel." It didn't look like that. It looked like a rock.
But oak leaves don't taste this fabulous. The oak leaf was covering bourbon cake, brown butter, and wintergreen "snow," which, appropriately, was frozen.
"Coal" wasn't on the menu we later received (as nor, I later learned, were several of the other things we had eaten). "Coal," we learned, was chocolate meringue that had been vacuum sealed, frozen, and then rolled in liquid nitrogen. When "Coal" arrived, dry-ice smoke was flowing off of it.
It was nearly midnight by now, three and a half hours after we sat down to eat a "quick bowl of moss" at Dwight and Jodi's little restaurant. With the exception of the "squid flake in bacon fat," about which I confess I shared the "slightly freaked out" feelings of the people of Portland, I had never eaten so many remarkable things in such rapid succession. The meal ended with "hazelnut truffles..."
And now it was time to find out how much of a contribution I was going to make to Dwight and Jodi's local startup. The information arrived in an envelope.
There's a saying about certain things in life that, if you have to ask how much it costs, you can't afford it. That's probably the attitude you should bring to Atera.
You're currently following this author!
Click to unsubscribe from email alerts.
Julie Zeveloff West is Director of Editorial Product Strategy at Business Insider. She was previously Chief of Staff to Business Insider's editor-in-chief.Julie was the editor-in-chief of the Life division, where she oversaw Business Insider's entertainment, health, food, travel, style, parenting, and digital culture coverage. She was also a Deputy Editor for the site's business section, where she oversaw the lifestyle, transportation, retail, education, and lists & rankings sections, as well as its social media and graphic design teams. Before joining Business Insider in 2010, she was a reporter at Law360, where she covered international trade.In 2019, she was chosen as one of the Folio: Top Women in Media honorees in the Up and Comers category. Julie graduated from Cornell University and holds a master's degree from Columbia University's Graduate School of Journalism.
You're currently following this author!
Click to unsubscribe from email alerts.
Henry Blodget cofounded Business Insider, then called "Silicon Alley Insider," in the loading dock of another New York-based startup in 2007. He served as Editor in Chief until 2017 and CEO until 2023. Business Insider is now owned by Axel Springer.A former top-ranked Wall Street analyst, Henry is often a guest on CNBC, CNN, MSNBC, NPR, and other networks. He has contributed to The Atlantic, Slate, The New York Times, Fortune, New York, the Financial Times, and other publications (including, of course, Business Insider!). He has written extensively about technology and investing and is the author of "The Wall Street Self-Defense Manual: A Consumer's Guide to Investing."
