Food

I tried 3 pickle-flavored products from Trader Joe's and the potato chips are the only item I'd buy again

Insider reporter Talia Lakritz holds up pickle-flavored products from Trader Joe's.
I tried a variety of pickle-flavored products from Trader Joe's. Talia Lakritz/Insider
Read in app

I visited the Trader Joe's store in Manhattan's SoHo neighborhood in search of pickle-flavored products.

The outside of a Trader Joe's store.
Trader Joe's in SoHo. Talia Lakritz/Insider

Trader Joe's is known for discontinuing products, so I asked an employee where I could find all of the store's pickle-flavored items. He said that only two products had lasted from the store's "pickle craze" over the summer — pickle-flavored potato chips and pickle-flavored peanuts.

The pickle-flavored potato chips cost $2.49 for a six-ounce bag.

Pickle-flavored potato chips for sale at Trader Joe's.
Pickle-flavored potato chips at Trader Joe's. Talia Lakritz/Insider

The chips appeared to be a popular item since there were only a few bags left on the shelf.

A six-ounce bag of pickle-flavored peanuts also cost $2.49.

Pickle-flavored peanuts for sale at Trader Joe's.
Pickle-flavored peanuts at Trader Joe's. Talia Lakritz/Insider

The shelf appeared almost fully stocked, which indicated to me that the peanuts might not be as much of a hit.

The availability of Trader Joe's "seasoning in a pickle" seasoning blend remains limited, but I remembered I'd bought a bottle over the summer that I'd never used.

Everything but the pickle seasoning from Trader Joe's.
Everything but the pickle seasoning from Trader Joe's. Talia Lakritz/Insider

According to the official Trader Joe's website, the pickle seasoning blend cost $2.49 for a 2.3-ounce bottle when it was available during its limited run. It's possible that the store will bring it back as a seasonal item this summer.

Those desperate for a supply can still find bottles on eBay and Amazon at much higher prices.

First, I tried the "Chips in a Pickle" potato chips.

Inside a bag of pickle-flavored potato chips from Trader Joe's.
The chips smelled amazing. Talia Lakritz/Insider

When I opened the bag, the delicious smell of salt and vinegar chips with a splash of dill pickle immediately made my mouth water.

The tangy flavor worked so well with the crispy, salty chips that I had to stop myself from eating the entire bag.

Insider reporter Talia Lakritz bites into a potato chip.
The pickle-flavored potato chips were delicious. Talia Lakritz/Insider

I could see why there weren't many bags of these chips left at Trader Joe's when I visited. I would definitely add a bag or two to my next Trader Joe's run.

I was a bit wary of the "Peanuts in a Pickle," but I gave them a try, as well.

A bag of pickle-flavored peanuts from Trader Joe's.
A bag of pickle-flavored peanuts from Trader Joe's. Talia Lakritz/Insider

Peanuts and pickles seemed like an odd flavor combination to me, but since Trader Joe's hasn't discontinued them yet, I figured they must be good.

I didn't love the mild flavor of the pickle-flavored peanuts as much as I had enjoyed the potato chips.

A handful of pickle-flavored peanuts from Trader Joe's.
Pickle-flavored peanuts. Talia Lakritz/Insider

For my palate, the pickle flavor didn't really shine through the nutty taste. To me, they just tasted like slightly sour peanuts.

Next, I tried the pickle seasoning on some homemade popcorn.

Adding pickle seasoning to a pot of popcorn.
I put the pickle seasoning on popcorn. Talia Lakritz/Insider

I popped some popcorn on the stove, added melted butter, and tossed it with some generous sprinkles of the pickle seasoning. Since the first ingredient in the seasoning blend was salt, I didn't add any more.

I thought the popcorn tasted great, but I didn't love how the seasoning blend turned the popcorn brown.

Pickle-flavored popcorn.
Pickle-flavored popcorn. Talia Lakritz/Insider

If only Trader Joe's Popcorn in a Pickle wasn't just a seasonal summer item. I would make this again, but I'd prefer to just open a bag of ready-made pickle-flavored popcorn instead of having to pop it myself.

The "Chips in a Pickle" are the only pickle-flavored Trader Joe's item I'd buy again.

A bag of pickle-flavored potato chips from Trader Joe's.
A bag of pickle-flavored potato chips from Trader Joe's. Talia Lakritz/Insider

For me, the pickle-flavored potato chips weren't just a novelty item that's fun to buy and try once. I plan on keeping a bag or two in my pantry for the next time I'm craving a tangy, salty treat.

Read next

Talia Lakritz
Talia Lakritz
Talia Lakritz is a Life correspondent at Business Insider covering politics and power through a visual storytelling lens. She has reported from the White House as well as military installations, mansions, and museums across the country, bringing readers inside fascinating places through immersive features.Previously, she wrote for The New York Jewish Week and SciShow Space.Talia holds a BA in English with a concentration in Creative Writing from Barnard College of Columbia University and ordination as an interfaith minister from One Spirit Learning Alliance. She hopes to one day visit all 50 states and all 14 public presidential libraries.Politics and power:Visual features:Human interest: